How blind is a blind eye? - Paris Smith Skip to content

29th January 2015

How blind is a blind eye?

SHARE

29th January 2015

How blind is a blind eye?


A defence that is sometimes used when a person is being asked to repay something which he/she has been mistakenly paid, or overpaid is that the person in question has changed their position/circumstance by (i) relying on the payment and (ii) then spending it!

Is this defence available to a person when the person in question knows that he/she shouldn’t have received the payment in the first place i.e.: can a person rely on the defence when they have turned a “blind eye” to their own knowledge?

The High Court in Webber v Department for Education [2014] EWHC 4240 (Ch) has gone some way to answering this question by partially allowing an appeal against a determination of the Deputy Pensions Ombudsman that had rejected a complaint by a member of the Teachers’ Pension Scheme about the recovery of overpaid pension instalments. The facts are that a teacher had taken early retirement but had then been re-employed a few years later. He had then informed the scheme administrator when he was re-employed, but maintained he was not aware he was obliged to tell the administrator about a subsequent salary increase that triggered statutory abatement provisions. He argued he had changed his position to his detriment in reliance on the overpayment through one-off and repeated expenditure.

The court held that if a person appreciated that a payment he was receiving may be an overpayment and could make a simple enquiry to check whether this was the case but chose not to do so, it would be inequitable to allow him to rely on a change of position defence. The case therefore implies that if a person turns “a blind eye”, this will usually be enough to stop a person arguing they have changed their position to their detriment.

Stay up to date with our latest industry news

By completing your details and submitting, you are consenting to us sending you relevant legal updates and invitations based on the areas of interest you select. For further details please read our privacy notice.